The Absolute Best Pizza in Fond Du Lac

Fond du Lac has a pizza problem, and it is a glorious one. You can watch the sunset melt over the lake at a place that also serves a righteous prime rib, or you can lose yourself in the quiet philosophical heft of a pie at Ala Roma, where the portions suggest you are feeding a militia.

The range here stretches from the tangy snap of a true Chicago-style deep dish at ANG an EDDIES to a Nutella dessert pizza that will make you forget the basketball game you came to watch. Our research involved a lot of nodding.

Consider this your map to the city's saucy, cheesy, and occasionally confusing corners.

Ala Roma Pizzeria & Pub

Highlights
Phenomenal pizza, huge portions
Kind staff and warm atmosphere
Cheesy breadsticks and fresh salads
Welcoming service, memorable experience

Ala Roma Pizzeria & Pub operates with a confidence that borders on philosophical. The pizza arrives with the kind of heft that makes you reconsider the structural integrity of the average cardboard box, and the portions suggest the kitchen believes you are feeding a small, hungry militia. The staff greet you like an old friend who owes them nothing, which is a rare and refreshing dynamic. Cheesy breadsticks arrive as golden, pull-apart monuments to dairy, while the salads taste like they were assembled by someone who actually respects lettuce. I left full, slightly disoriented, and already planning my return. The warmth is not manufactured. It simply exists, like humidity or the concept of Thursday.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Appleton.

ANG an EDDIES

Highlights
Deep dish sauce spot on
Thin crust surprisingly excellent
True Chicago Italian beef
Worth revisiting while nearby

ANG an EDDIES operates on a logic that is both baffling and beautiful. The deep dish sauce has a tang that snaps you to attention, while the thin crust performs a delicate balancing act between crackle and chew that I did not expect from a place whose name suggests a grammatical error. The Italian beef is a true Chicago specimen, dripping with jus and demanding immediate consumption. I found myself nodding at the table like a fool, approving of choices I did not make. This is a place you revisit out of obligation to your own happiness. The crust alone justifies the trip across town. Consider this a formal apology to the owners for ever doubting an ampersand.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Stevens Point.

Gino's Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Pasta dishes are superb
Warm, engaging bar staff
Quick takeout service
Fresh food, fair price
Relaxing dining environment

Gino's Italian Restaurant is the kind of place where the pasta does the talking and the bar staff listen with an engaging warmth that makes you forget the weather outside. The marinara tastes like it has been simmering since before you were born, and the portions arrive with a generosity that borders on reckless. I ordered takeout and was astounded by the speed, as if the kitchen had anticipated my hunger before I even chose the pizza. The dining room encourages a slow, contemplative pace, ideal for staring at your own reflection in a wine glass. Fair prices, fresh ingredients, and a bar tender who remembers your name. The pizza is solid, but the pasta is the real protagonist here.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Oshkosh.

Cellar District

Highlights
Stunning historic building
Warm, welcoming atmosphere
Beautifully designed interior
Thoughtfully crafted details
Inviting, character-rich space

Cellar District is a building that remembers things. The historic bones of the place radiate a quiet authority, and the interior design has been executed with a care that suggests someone actually thought about where the light would fall at 4 p.m. The atmosphere is warm in a way that makes you want to whisper, not out of reverence, but because the walls seem to be listening. I came for a slice and stayed for the sheer pleasure of sitting in a space that respects its own history. The pizza is fine, but the room is the main course. You could serve a slice of construction paper on a plate here and I would still leave satisfied, though perhaps less full.

You might also want to check out the best bar in Sheboygan.

Capones

Highlights
Fresh food, always a win
Curd burger and fries shine
Fried brat bites out of this world
Fast drinks and speedy service
Top notch service, excellent server

Capones has a staff that moves like they are in a perfectly choreographed fever dream. The curd burger arrives with a molten, squeaky crown of cheese curds, and the fries are the kind of crispy, salty odes to potato that make you question why other fries even bother. The fried brat bites are a revelation, small spheres of porky ecstasy that I would happily eat until the heat death of the universe. Drinks materialize quickly, and the service is so attentive that I checked my own pulse to see if I was being monitored. The pizza here plays a supporting role, but it is a solid one. Fresh ingredients, fast execution, and a server who could probably run a small country.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Sturgeon Bay.

Cowlicks Cones and Floats

Highlights
Popping boba earns raves
Ice cream flavors consistently great
Cozy, fun summer atmosphere
Friendly, helpful staff recommendations

Cowlicks Cones and Floats is a summer institution that operates on a principle of joyful excess. The popping boba are little orbs of rebellion that burst in your mouth, and the ice cream flavors rotate with the unpredictability of a weather system. I asked for a recommendation and received a detailed, enthusiastic lecture that made me feel like I was being briefed on a diplomatic mission. The atmosphere is cozy and fun, the kind of place where you can eat too much sugar and stare at the sunset without embarrassment. The waffle cone is crisp, the portions are generous, and the staff genuinely care about your dessert trajectory. I left with a brain freeze and a newfound respect for the humble float.

You might also want to check out the best wings in Appleton.

Romero's Taco Truck

Highlights
Flavorful quesabirria, fresh guac
Best authentic Mexican tacos
Daily crew favorite spot
Travelers’ top local choice

Romero's Taco Truck operates from a position of no-nonsense excellence. The quesabirria is a masterclass in flavor, with a consommé that could bring a grown person to tears, and the fresh guacamole tastes like it was mashed moments before you arrived. These are the best authentic tacos I have had in Fond du Lac, and I say that with the authority of someone who has eaten many tacos in many questionable locations. The crew clearly eats here daily, which is always a good sign, and travelers seem to find it through some mysterious word-of-mouth network. The truck itself is unassuming, but the food is a loud, delicious statement. I would cross state lines for this birria. I might actually do it.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Ludington.

Coliseum Sports Bar and Grill

Highlights
Spacious with abundant game-viewing TVs
Nutella dessert pizza surprisingly excellent
Attentive bar service when present
Quiet, uncrowded seating available

Coliseum Sports Bar and Grill is a cavernous space of screens and scattered seating, where the pizza plays second fiddle to the game but occasionally steals the show. The Nutella dessert pizza is a surprisingly excellent confection, a sweet disc of hazelnut excess that made me forget I was watching a basketball game I did not care about. The bar service is attentive when it exists, which is to say, during lulls you are left to your own devices, but that is fine because the quiet corners are abundant and comfortable. I sat in a half-empty section and felt like a king in exile. The standard pizza is serviceable, but the dessert pizza is a reason to invent new occasions to celebrate.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Ludington.

Tomaso's

Highlights
Fresh sauce with rich flavor
Excellent gluten free crust options
Welcoming staff and owner
Unique toppings like anchovies, garlic
House made chips worth trying

Tomaso's is a place that understands the quiet art of tomato sauce. The sauce is fresh, rich, and possesses a depth that suggests a relationship between the chef and the can opener that borders on spiritual. The gluten free crust is a revelation, achieving a texture that does not taste like punishment, and the option to top your pie with anchovies and garlic is a sign of a kitchen that respects tradition but also enjoys a good argument. The owner greeted me like I had wandered into his living room, and the house made chips are a salty, crunchy side quest worth completing. This is the kind of pizza place that makes you reconsider your allegiances. I left with a newfound respect for gluten-free dining and a faint smell of garlic on my fingers.

You might also want to check out the best bar in Wausau.

Sunset On The Water

Highlights
Sunset views over lake
Friendly, knowledgeable service
Quiet, warm atmosphere
Excellent prime rib and shrimp
Great value for groups

Sunset On The Water is a location that understands its own name. The dining room faces the lake with a quiet, warm intimacy, and the view at dusk is the kind of spectacle that makes you forget your pizza is getting cold. The service is friendly and knowledgeable, offering suggestions with a confidence that suggests they have eaten everything on the menu. The prime rib is excellent, and the shrimp are plump and succulent, but the pizza is a humble, well-made companion to the scenery. The value is exceptional for groups, and the atmosphere encourages long conversations and even longer stares at the horizon. I came for the sunset and stayed for the prime rib. The pizza is just there, doing its job, like a reliable friend who doesn't need applause.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in West Bend.

Kelley Country Creamery

Highlights
Rotating flavors keep visits fresh
Sampler platters ease tough choices
Secondary stand offers line-free options
Staff friendliness rounds out experience

Kelley Country Creamery is a rotating door of flavors that makes commitment an existential crisis. The sampler platters are a godsend, allowing you to try six flavors without the guilt of choosing wrong, and the secondary stand offers a line-free route to sweet salvation that feels like cheating the system. The ice cream is consistently great, with a texture that is dense and creamy without being heavy, and the staff are friendly enough to explain the difference between a cone and a cup as if it matters. I tried a flavor that tasted like a campfire and another that tasted like a birthday party, and both were excellent. This is not a pizza place, but it is a necessary stop after pizza. The rotating flavors ensure you never have the same experience twice.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Stevens Point.

11:11 Burgers & Beignets

Highlights
Excellent service, delicious fresh burgers
Crispy fries worth the visit
Filling portions at fair price
Floors need a refresh soon

11:11 Burgers & Beignets is a place that serves excellent burgers and fries, and the pizza is conspicuously absent from the menu, but I am reviewing it anyway because the fries are that good. The service is excellent, and the burgers arrive fresh and juicy, with a ratio of bun to meat that suggests the chef has a degree in structural engineering. The portions are filling, and the prices are fair, which is a rare combination in this economy. The beignets are a sweet, powdered sugar interlude that makes you forget the burger you just demolished. The floors, however, need a refresh, and the tiles look like they have survived a war. I still recommend this place, but wear shoes you do not love.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Green Bay.