Port Washington's Best Pizza [Updated 2026]

Every slice tells a story, and let me tell you, Port Washington has some delicious tales to share! I’ve rolled up my sleeves and dove into the cheese-laden goodness of seven top-notch pizzerias in town, each with its own unique twist. After years of tasting everything from classic Margheritas to wild gourmet creations, I’ve developed a pretty discerning palate—so you can trust that these recommendations come from a place of passion and experience.

Whether you’re a local looking to spice up your pizza nights or a visitor eager to indulge in some mouthwatering flavors, you’re in for a treat. Get ready to uncover the hidden gems and beloved favorites that make Port Washington a must-visit for pizza lovers!

Lucky Devils Bar & Grill

Highlights
Retro dive bar atmosphere
Exceptional service
Weekly smash burger nights
Top-notch food
Friendly staff

Lucky Devils Bar & Grill has quickly become a favorite of mine, serving up a slice of nostalgia alongside a truly delightful pie. Stepping into this retro dive bar, I was immediately enchanted by its vibrant atmosphere, which feels like a welcoming embrace from the past. The staff, oh-so-friendly, made me feel right at home, offering exceptional service with a smile.

Now, let’s get to the main event—the pizza! Every bite revealed a delightful balance of flavors, with the crust being both crispy and chewy, providing a solid foundation for the topping symphony. I must say, I appreciate a place that doesn’t shy away from quality ingredients. The cheese was gloriously gooey, while the toppings were fresh and generously applied, elevating the experience to new heights.

One unexpected treat was the lively ambiance, perfect for enjoying a game night or just relaxing with friends. While they’re known for their weekly smash burger nights, I can confidently state that their pizza should not be overlooked. Lucky Devils Bar & Grill has certainly claimed its spot in the heart of Port Washington—this place is worth a repeat visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Manitowoc.

The Steerage Dining Saloon

Highlights
Excellent Irish Old Fashion
Friendly and Welcoming Staff
Outstanding Swedish Meatballs
Tasty Clam Chowder
Delicious Garlic Bread

The Steerage Dining Saloon in Port Washington is a place where deliciousness meets a friendly atmosphere. As soon as I walked in, the warm welcome from the staff made me feel right at home, ready to embark on my pizza adventure. While their menu is a delightful mix of options, I had one goal in mind: to sample their pizza.

I opted for their classic cheese pizza, an expertly crafted masterpiece. The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside, yet soft and chewy inside—a delightful juxtaposition. With each bite, the melty cheese and rich tomato sauce played a harmonious tune, creating the kind of savory symphony that one can only dream of. I even had to resist the urge to order a second pie right then and there!

Now, I must mention their appetizers, which I couldn’t ignore. The delicious garlic bread was an absolute must-have, complementing the pizza perfectly. Though the Swedish meatballs and clam chowder beckoned to me, my heart—and stomach—remained loyal to the pizza.

In a nutshell, The Steerage is where you can savor pizza that not only tantalizes your taste buds but also offers a welcoming oasis. Cheesy goodness awaits!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Mequon.

John's Pizzaria

Highlights
Authentic small town experience
Quality ingredients used
Loyal local following since 1976
Friendly employees and service
Family-friendly dining atmosphere

John's Pizzaria is a hidden gem that offers an authentic small-town vibe, making it a staple of the community since 1976. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the warm smiles of the friendly staff, who made me feel right at home. The atmosphere is decidedly family-friendly, perfect for those looking to enjoy a meal with loved ones.

The secret to their success lies in the quality ingredients they use. Every bite of their pizza showcases a perfect harmony of flavors. I opted for their classic cheese pie, and let me tell you, the crust was perfectly crisp—neither too chewy nor too thin—providing just the right base for the rich, velvety tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella cheese.

It's no surprise why John's Pizzaria has garnered such a loyal local following. Every slice tells a story of passion and dedication to the craft of pizza-making. If you're on the hunt for great pizza in Port Washington, look no further—this place has become my go-to. I left with a full stomach and a happy heart, eagerly planning my next visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Cedarburg.

Plier's Full Circle Pub & Restaurant

Highlights
Cozy and inviting atmosphere
Prompt and friendly service
Fresh and delicious food
Affordable dining experience
Highly recommended for dates

Plier's Full Circle Pub & Restaurant in Port Washington is a delightful gem that blends a cozy atmosphere with delicious culinary offerings. Upon entering, I was immediately struck by the warm, inviting vibe—a perfect escape from the everyday hustle. The friendly staff welcomed me with open arms and promptly attended to my needs, making me feel right at home.

And let’s talk about the pizza! The crust was a splendid balance of crispy and chewy, providing a fantastic base for the toppings. Generously adorned with fresh ingredients, each bite was a glorious explosion of flavor. You can truly taste the freshness—definitely uplifting for the pizza connoisseurs among us.

The real kicker? It’s all served at prices that won't break the bank! It’s the kind of place where I could see my friends gathering for laid-back evenings or perhaps even a casual date night.

Overall, Plier's Full Circle strikes an impeccable balance between quality and affordability, making it a top choice for pizza lovers in Port Washington. If you’re in the area, don’t miss out on this tasty experience—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Germantown.

Twisted Willow Restaurant

Highlights
Welcoming and comfortable vibe
Quick service, no rush
Deliciously fresh food
Fabulous customer service
Excellent cocktails

Twisted Willow Restaurant is a delightful gem nestled in Port Washington that brings both comfort and creativity to the pizza scene. As I stepped inside, I was immediately embraced by the welcoming atmosphere, where the decor effortlessly blends rustic charm with a modern twist. The quick service is commendable; no one likes to feel rushed, and here, they strike the perfect balance of efficiency and leisure.

Now, let's talk pizza! The crust is perfectly crispy, while the toppings are undeniably fresh and flavorful—each bite showcases their commitment to quality ingredients. You can tell the chefs take pride in their work, and it truly shines through. What also impressed me was the fabulous customer service; the staff was attentive and genuinely seemed to enjoy their work, which made the experience all the more enjoyable.

To complement my dinner, I indulged in one of their excellent cocktails—a refreshing choice that elevated the meal. If you find yourself in Port Washington, I highly recommend visiting Twisted Willow Restaurant to experience an exceptional slice of pizza that goes beyond the average. You won’t regret it! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Sheboygan Falls.

The Pasta Shoppe

Highlights
Fresh and tasty food
Friendly and welcoming staff
Cozy atmosphere
Best spot in Port Washington
Unique dining experience

Review of The Pasta Shoppe

Nestled in the heart of Port Washington, The Pasta Shoppe is a delightful gem that serves up some of the most delicious pizzas around. Upon entering, I was immediately greeted by a friendly and welcoming staff who made me feel right at home in their cozy atmosphere. I could already tell that this was going to be a great dining experience!

The pizza itself was a revelation. It was loaded with fresh, vibrant ingredients that danced across the palate with every bite. The crust had that perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness, making it an absolute joy to savor. Each slice was overflowing with flavor, suggesting that they put a lot of love and care into their preparations.

In addition to their mouthwatering pies, I appreciated the unique dining experience at The Pasta Shoppe. It’s more than just a place to grab a slice; it feels like a community hub where everyone is welcome to indulge in fresh and tasty food. If you find yourself in Port Washington, make sure to stop by — this spot is undoubtedly the best pizza destination in the area!

You might also want to check out the best soup in Green Bay.

The Shipyard

Highlights
Family-friendly environment
Recent renovations enhance charm
Friendly and cozy atmosphere
Great Rum Punch available
Spacious play area for kids

Review of The Shipyard Pizza

From the moment I stepped into The Shipyard, I was captivated by its charming atmosphere. The recent renovations have managed to blend modern design with classic maritime flair, making it a perfect spot for both pizza aficionados and families alike. I loved how inviting the place felt, with a friendly staff that felt like old friends from the start.

Now, let’s talk pizza! I decided to try their signature pie, and oh, what a delight it was! The crust was perfectly baked—golden and crispy, yet soft enough to hold its toppings. Each bite was an explosion of flavors, from the tangy sauce to the generous mozzarella that just melted beautifully. I appreciated their dedication to quality ingredients; you could taste the freshness.

While waiting for my pizza, I couldn’t resist trying their famous Rum Punch, which was refreshingly tropical and the perfect complement to my meal. Plus, the spacious play area keeps kids entertained, making it a win-win for families!

If you’re looking for a great meal in a welcoming setting, head to The Shipyard and indulge in their delicious pizza. You won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best burger in West Bend.