Marinette's Best Restaurant

Marinette has exactly one pasty shop worth your time and one former Applebee’s that somehow serves better birria than half of Milwaukee. That’s the range here: a veterinary clinic that loves your dog more than you do, and a supper club pouring top-tier Old Fashioneds.

We crunched the cheese curds, the raw chicken, and the grasshopper drinks so you don’t have to. One warning: skip the turkey club.

Read on.

Tom and Jen's Pasty Company

Highlights
Historic family pasty recipes
Handmade pasta with gravy
Modern twists on classics
Hearty, handheld tradition
Near Lake Michigan storefront

Tom and Jen’s Pasty Company sits near the lake, but the food is pure Upper Peninsula tradition. The historic family recipes show up in every flaky, gravy-filled bite. Handmade pasta with gravy is a sleeper hit. These are sturdy, hearty hand pies meant for cold weather and empty stomachs. The modern twists on classics are subtle but welcome. Service is efficient, if brisk. This is a handheld tradition done right. No gimmicks, just solid comfort food. I’d eat here weekly and not apologize. Bring a napkin. Actually, bring two.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Wausau.

Monarca Mexican Bar & Grill

Highlights
Generous tender birria portions
Authentic thin crispy chips
Fresh lively house salsas
Swift friendly multi-server service
Spacious clean former Applebee's

Monarca occupies the old Applebee’s space, and it’s a massive improvement. The birria portions are generous, with tender meat that falls apart on contact. Chips arrive thin, crisp, and authentically salty. The house salsas are fresh and lively, not watery excuses. Service is swift, with multiple servers checking in like they’re on a mission. The dining room is spacious and clean, a rarity for a former chain. Portions justify the price. This is a solid, no-nonsense Mexican spot. I left full, satisfied, and slightly annoyed I couldn’t eat more.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Manitowoc.

Klema's Wisconsin Cheese

Highlights
Clean, orderly, stocked shelves
Friendly staff, great ice cream
Worth every single stop
Strong cheese and liquor picks

Klema’s isn’t a restaurant, but it deserves a spot on any food list. The shelves are clean, orderly, and stocked with a cheese selection that mocks supermarket blocks. The staff is friendly, and the ice cream is genuinely great. Worth every single stop, whether you’re grabbing curds for a cookout or a bottle from the liquor aisle. The cheese picks are strong, literally and figuratively. This place understands Wisconsin. It’s a pit stop, a destination, and a cheesehead’s paradise all at once. Just don’t expect table service. You don’t need it.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Mequon.

Rene's Dining Room

Highlights
Tenderloin on hot plate
Best grasshopper ice cream drinks
Polite, attentive staff service
Reasonable prices for quality
Ideal for family or romantic dinners

Rene’s Dining Room is old school, and I mean that as a compliment. The tenderloin arrives sizzling on a hot plate, a glorious throwback that demands your full attention. The grasshopper ice cream drinks are the best in town, sweet, minty, and dangerously drinkable. Service is polite and attentive without hovering. Prices are reasonable for the quality, which feels like a miracle these days. It’s ideal for a family dinner or a quiet romantic evening. The room doesn’t try to be trendy. It doesn’t have to. It just works. Bring an appetite and a sense of nostalgia.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Cedarburg.

The Bagel Shoppe & Cafe

Highlights
Friendly staff, ample variety
Best bagels in area
Cute, nostalgic storefront
Berry smoothie highly recommended
Turkey club needs warming

The Bagel Shoppe & Cafe is a nostalgic storefront with a friendly vibe. The bagels are the best in the area, no contest. Chewy, dense, and properly boiled. The berry smoothie is highly recommended, a cold, thick burst of flavor. The turkey club, however, needs warming. Cold meat on a cold sandwich in a cold climate? No. Get the smoothie, grab a bagel, and skip the club. The staff is sweet and the variety is ample. It’s a charming spot with a clear strength. Stick to the bready classics and you’ll leave happy. Just don’t order the lukewarm sandwich.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Beaver Dam.

Riverside Country Club

Highlights
Exceptional private event execution
Exemplary service under pressure
Chef-prepared food praised universally
Scenic, clean, well-run venue
Ideal for weddings and celebrations

Riverside Country Club handles events like they’ve done it a thousand times. Because they have. The service is exemplary under pressure, a rare thing when a wedding crowd is hungry and impatient. The chef-prepared food gets universal praise, which is more than you can say for most venues. The space is scenic, clean, and well-run. If you’re planning a celebration, put this on the shortlist. It’s not secret, but it should be. The staff anticipates needs before you ask. That’s skill. I didn’t want to leave. I also didn’t want to admit I was impressed. I was.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Germantown.

Lauerman House Inn

Highlights
Historic home, modern comfort
Homemade breakfast, never microwaved
Spacious rooms with river views
Welcoming host, attentive staff
Charming lower-level lounge space

Lauerman House Inn is a historic home that offers modern comfort without losing its soul. The breakfast is made from scratch and you can tell. Nothing here comes out of a microwave. Nothing. The rooms are spacious, and river views are a quiet luxury. The host is welcoming, and the staff is attentive. There’s a charming lower-level lounge that feels like a secret. This is the kind of place you book for a weekend and instantly regret leaving. It’s not flashy, but it doesn’t need to be. It’s a home with better service and better pancakes.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Antigo.

Nightingale Supper Club | Steakhouse

Highlights
Prime rib is stellar
Old Fashioneds rank top-tier
Chef’s special surprises
Kid-friendly options deliver

Nightingale Supper Club knows steak. The prime rib is stellar, seasoned well and cooked to order. The Old Fashioneds are top-tier, a proper balance of sweet, bitter, and boozy. The chef’s special surprises, so let them take a risk. The kitchen covers the classics and does them right. Kid-friendly options actually work, which is rarer than it should be. Service is professional but relaxed. This is a supper club that understands its role. You come for the meat, you stay for the drinks. You leave planning your return. Simple as that.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Merrill.

Welcker's Lounge

Highlights
Walleye and duck shine
Sides deserve solo billing
Attentive, welcoming service
Music sets the vibe
Cheesecake worth remembering

Welcker’s Lounge is a lounge, but the food punches above its weight. Walleye and duck are the stars, cooked with confidence and little fuss. The sides deserve solo billing; they’re not afterthoughts, they’re supporting actors who steal scenes. Service is attentive and welcoming, even when the place fills up. Music sets the vibe, not too loud, not too low. The cheesecake is worth remembering, which means I’ll be thinking about it all week. This is a neighborhood spot with a kitchen that cares. Go for a drink, stay for dinner. You’ll be surprised. I was.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Weston.

Poseidons

Highlights
Raw chicken at weddings
Drunk owner, poor service
Short ribs good thrice
Closed, limited bar menu
Best area food, maybe

Poseidons is a mess, and not in a charming way. I saw raw chicken at a wedding. Raw. The owner appeared drunk, and service was poor. The short ribs were good three times, which only makes the inconsistency more frustrating. The place is closed now, and the bar menu is limited. And yet, there’s a small part of me that thinks this was the best food in the area, maybe. Maybe. It’s a gamble every visit. You might get a great meal or a stomach bug. I’m not sure I’d risk it again. But I’m also not sure I wouldn’t.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Sheboygan Falls.

Town & Country Veterinary Clinic

Highlights
Caring, knowledgeable veterinarians
Listens to every concern
Accommodating emergency scheduling
Genuinely loves your pets

This is a veterinary clinic, not a restaurant, but if your pet is sick, this is where you want them. The vets are caring, knowledgeable, and actually listen. They don’t rush you through. They take every concern seriously. Emergency scheduling is accommodating, which is crucial when you’re panicked and your dog ate something stupid. They genuinely love your pets, and it shows. No food, but a lot of heart. In a town full of restaurants, this is the one place I trust without hesitation. Bring your dog. Skip the menu. There isn’t one.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Whitefish Bay.

LOFT

Highlights
Perfectly presented, delicious meals
Chef’s chicken curry bowl standout
Server CC’s impeccable timing
Bartender Luigi’s warm hospitality

The LOFT delivers exactly what it promises: perfectly presented, delicious meals. The chef’s chicken curry bowl is a standout, creamy, spicy, and deep. Server CC has impeccable timing, appearing when you need her and disappearing when you don’t. Bartender Luigi adds warmth to the bar, and his hospitality is genuine. The room feels polished without feeling stuffy. This is polished dining done right. Not a false note. I came for lunch and stayed for an extra coffee. I’d do it again. This place is confident, and rightly so. Order the curry. You won’t regret it.

You might also want to check out the best restaurant in Howard.